It is literally a thin wire, but it has created a wide chasm that is splitting Williamsburg's Hasidic community.
The wire, known as an eruv, is strung from poles along the perimeter of
a portion of the ultra-Orthodox Jewish northern Brooklyn neighborhood.
Although it weighs practically nothing, it is heavy with symbolism:
once inside its boundaries, Hasidim can, for example, carry a prayer
shawl, lean on a cane or push a baby stroller on the Sabbath.
According to Judaic law that has stood for thousands of years, unless
an eruv is in place, it is forbidden to carry anything outdoors on that
day of rest.
But the Hasidic community in Williamsburg has
become so divided over whether an eruv should be put up that doctrinal
debates have erupted into fistfights. A recent series of brawls led to
arrests.
Opponents of the eruv and the "walls" it creates see it
as an affront to their faith and a sin. Its supporters counter that
when properly sanctioned by a rabbi, the eruv makes their lives easier.
"It's a perfect thing," said a 43-year-old Hasidic mother, waiting on a
local street last week to pick up her young daughter after school.
"Disabled children and older people in wheelchairs can go to synagogue.
Mothers with little babies, they wouldn't have to hire a baby-sitter."
But just across the street, a 32-year-old mother of five children said simply, "We're against it because our rabbi said so."
The women - like most others interviewed, they declined to give their
names - aren't alone in their divided opinions about the wire.
In the week after Passover this year - around the time a communitywide
eruv was erected - screaming matches erupted between men carrying,
rather than wearing, fur hats on the Sabbath and those who opposed the
practice. At times, the verbal confrontations escalated into violent
shoving matches.
Five arrests
When fighting broke out
on the streets on Saturday, April 26, police moved in and arrested five
Hasidic men on disorderly conduct charges.
"We have to make sure
we protect everyone's religious beliefs," said Deputy Inspector Larry
Nikunen, commander of the 90th Precinct in Williamsburg. But, he added,
"It's a safety issue when you're dealing with a large crowd."
Police have beefed up area patrols.
The exact location of the eruv is known only to those who put it up.
They say it generally runs along Kent Ave., east on Broadway to
Flushing Ave., south on Warsoff Place to Willoughby Ave. and up Taaffe
Place. One 23-year-old man who lives in the neighborhood says the
wire's precise location is a closely guarded secret.
"They don't give out where it is," he said. "That way no one will break it."