בית פורומים חדשות אנש עולם הנגינה

Analog Vs. Digital

שלום אורח. באפשרותך להתחבר או להירשם
הצג 15 הודעות בעמוד הוסף לדף האישי  דווח למנהל שלח לחבר
נשלח ב-14/2/2006 05:24 לינק ישיר 
Analog Vs. Digital

i think that the subject of analog vs. digital goes beyond the actual sound of analog and digital. 

true, analog has that certain sound, and in some instruments it can sound very pleasing but bear in mind that the sound that you're hearing isnt an exact replica of the original source. the "saturation" that you're hearing is an addition to the signal. with digital what you hear is whats happening ( not always a good thing

now as to my opinion on the subject: i think that now adays people are so busy with getting that vintage sound that the whole production suffers. people are spending thousands of dollars on soundelux and neumann mics on vintage preamps and compressors, on plug-ins that emulate vintage sound (kind of an oxymoron, no?) if they only focus as much on the recording process as they do on equipment.

i once heard a soundclip from someone who wanted to express the importance of mic placement, he had recorded a drumset, had mixed it, eq'd, etc etc and dared anyone to guess the combination of mics he had used. turns out he had recorded the whole set from overheads to bass drum with ......... yup you guessed it the famous SM57.

now im not saying that quality mics dont sound better, but what i am saying is that mic PLACEMENT is so much more important.

and the same goes for the actual production as well. if a great producer will work on a recording and he will use great musicians and a great arranger, mixing and mastering enigineers and the actual songs and singers will be great, when you will hear the final product you will be so amazed that you wont even BEGIN to think "hmmmmm...... its missing that analog sound" 

 so this is how stuff ranks in the audio world in my opinion

 1production by this i mean content of the recording 
2musicians and singers
3mixing/ mastering engineer
4recording engineer
5equipment, mics pre's compressors etc etc


Your opinions please.  




דווח על תוכן פוגעני

מנותק
נשלח ב-14/2/2006 19:33 לינק ישיר 

OK MUZAKAL



This is a toughie



Here is are some of my opinions



Content and producing are two different things all together, good content is of course key, and a good producer will bring it all together, and even save you some money



 



The musicians are really only as good as the arrangement is, if you have good arrangements that are properly written any studio musician will be able to perform somewhat ''up to par''  with your expectations



 



The singers, ay ya yay what a touché subject. A lot of us make money on people that have wonderful dreams and perhaps not so wonderful voices. A person with a phenomenal voice will not necessarily be successful and there are those with the voice of a crow that have made it, I think that ''content'' plays a huge role, and of course marketing! If you can convince people that your product is the best they will buy it regardless of quality



 



Recording Engineers are very important, as they are the first step in putting sound waves to tape, (or disc). If they do a lousy job it will be felt all the way down the line. There are many tricks and techniques to proper mic'ing. I think that most engineers want to get a sound that's as natural as possible personally I think that the '57 is a great mic to use be it in studio or on a live gig. I can't get into the details 'cause I am really not that familiar but there are different placements for all kinds of scenarios, i.e. strings, horns, woodwinds, vocals, drums, and a combination of any of those, I have played in studios where the engineer has had me play in every corner of the room 'till he found the ''sound'' that he liked but that's what makes a great recording engineer, a person that knows what he, or his client is looking for and KNOWS how to achieve that as naturally as possible



 



Mixing is a subject that we can fill pages on. His job is to make everything sound pleasant. All I will say on the subject is in my opinion, it is best to find a mixing engineer that did not have any ties to the project up to this point, that includes recording, ALSO it is best to find an engineer that does not play any of the instruments that he is mixing, 'cause inevitably he will mix the music to bring out the sound that is most pleasing to HIS ear, rather than what the producer, and in turn the general public would have liked to hear



 



Mastering simply put is leveling everything out, EQ etc. a good mastering engineer will put the perfect polish on your project, but the polishing is only as good as the subject content therein



 



Compressors etc. as I am not an engineer I will leave it to the engineers of the forum to comment



תוקן על ידי - bflat - 14/02/2006 19:34:34



דדווח על תוכן פוגעני

מנותק
נשלח ב-15/2/2006 02:18 לינק ישיר 

ok mr. B-Flat, here me out.

first of all i think that the producer is tied very closely with the actuall content of the recording, as a producer will only work with content that he feels meets his standards.

second, musicians play an important roll in the performance and i think your statement is plain and simple WRONG. you can give the same sheet to avi singolda and lets say for example mike coon and i guarentee that it wont sound the same. and the same goes for every other instrument, rick cutler and asher pedi, arkady kofman and peter vertheimer, etc etc.

oh and kudos on your comments on mixing, i agree 100%, never mix your own recordings 




דדווח על תוכן פוגעני

מנותק
נשלח ב-15/2/2006 02:28 לינק ישיר 

So bottom line, analog or digital? l



דדווח על תוכן פוגעני

מחובר
נשלח ב-15/2/2006 06:38 לינק ישיר 

Bottom Line......... with a great production it really doesnt matter! I




דדווח על תוכן פוגעני

מנותק
נשלח ב-16/2/2006 04:00 לינק ישיר 

Oh you not gonna get me started on this subject turkey (just kidding() but even though you are 100% right about contents but digital vs. analogue is a very touchy subject with no right or wrong..... it's up to the individual.... and in my case the indi likes the analogue better.... you know its kinda like cooking a chicken soup and putting in a measured amount of ingredients and cooking it for a very exact time the exact same amount of salt grains cooked is a sterile inviroment...... the good old haimishe chicken soup were you just pour the salt, add to ingridients, over cook - under cook etc etc will taste betterand will be more authentic. Digital is not the exact recxording the way the instrument sounds.... it's processed and filtered much more and lacks the life and authenticity.... in my HUMBLE opinion.



דדווח על תוכן פוגעני

מנותק
נשלח ב-16/2/2006 10:51 לינק ישיר 

oh and the ranking...........yhis is my version 1...mix 2...singer 3...music (arranger, musicians) etc 4...recording engineer 5... etc .compositions 7/8...recording equipment :addSymbol('wink.gif');



דדווח על תוכן פוגעני

מנותק
נשלח ב-16/2/2006 15:03 לינק ישיר 

wow, you think that recording engineer is more important than composition?  must be that in turkey we do things differently

i wonder why happyjew isnt doing us the honor of giving us his opinion? I




דדווח על תוכן פוגעני

מנותק
נשלח ב-16/2/2006 16:49 לינק ישיר 

He be very busy conducting his virtual symphonic orchestra,  I hear that the Koh Ribon song is a massive hit




דדווח על תוכן פוגעני

מנותק
נשלח ב-16/2/2006 18:11 לינק ישיר 

Symphonic Orchestra?????? what am i missing here



דדווח על תוכן פוגעני

מנותק
נשלח ב-16/2/2006 18:36 לינק ישיר 

Personal opinion

1
song

2
song

3
song

4
Star singer like Amit

5
Arranger

6
type of music - live or sampled/synth

7
recording studio

8
mix

911
ויבקש רחמים

תוקן על ידי - happyjew - 16/02/2006 18:53:37 תוקן על ידי - happyjew - 16/02/2006 19:07:36



דדווח על תוכן פוגעני

מחובר
נשלח ב-16/2/2006 19:00 לינק ישיר 

hyde talk some thing like this http://www.garritan.com/images/Plank.gif but not actually this program



דדווח על תוכן פוגעני

מחובר
נשלח ב-17/2/2006 18:35 לינק ישיר 

which brings us to a whole different topic, real instruments vs. fake




דדווח על תוכן פוגעני

מנותק
   
בית > פורומים > אקטואליה וחדשות > חדשות אנש עולם הנגינה > Analog Vs. Digital
מנהל לחץ כאן לנעילת האשכול
הוסף לעמוד האישי  דווח למנהל שלח לחבר

bholext