Rabbi's wig ruling creates alarm among some who keep kosher
Orthodox Jewish women wear wigs to hide their hair in the interests of modesty. Some panicked when an Israeli rabbi questioned whether wig hair from India is kosher.
By ELINOR J. BRECHER
[email protected]
Within hours after a revered Orthodox rabbi in Israel declared that human hair wigs from India might violate Jewish law, the phone at Alisa's Wigs and Hats in Miami Beach started jangling.
''Women were crying hysterically,'' said Alisa Weiss, longtime purveyor of headgear to religious women. ''They were panicking. They came here with their husbands!''
That an Orthodox man might penetrate this inner sanctum of femininity speaks to the stunning impact of Rabbi Yosef Shalom Elyashiv's May 13 pronouncement.
The leader of the Lithuanian Torah Jewry faction declared that Indian hair could have been cut in a Hindu temple, part of a sacrificial rite that Jews would consider idolatrous. One strand in a human-hair wig would render it unfit, he ruled.
Jewish law requires married women to dress modestly, which includes a head covering in front of everyone except her husband. Some wear wigs -- sheitels, in Yiddish -- some wear hats, some wear both.
Women in the ultra-religious enclaves around the world began to jettison -- even publicly immolating -- hairpieces costing thousands of dollars, then stampeded the stores for $75 synthetic replacements.
''The rush is totally out of control,'' said Joseph Este, an online seller at Miami Beach-based wigsalon.com, who advertises ''kosher wigs.''
Orthodox women account for 15-20 percent of his human-hair wig sales, said Este. Now customers ''are wanting [synthetic] wigs quickly and we're running out of shades of brown.''
Before the rabbi's statement, Este said synthetics were 93 percent of his business. They're acceptable under Jewish law because their raw materials have a man-made, rather then human, origin. ''Now it's probably 98 percent.''
According to his site, ''The only wigs that can be trusted are 100 percent synthetics, and 100 percent European hair wigs when the vendors are reliable and with well-documented sources.''
Wig connoisseurs consider European products the finest: The hair is delicate and each of approximately 150,000 strands is hand knotted to a mesh cap. They can cost up to $10,000. Indian hair is coarser and artificially colored. Still, these wigs can fetch $1,000.
Synthetics are heavy, sweaty and clearly fake, said Weiss, which make them desirable because they minimize allure.
She donned a long, flowing human hair wig, noting features that would earn the strictest authorities' disapproval: ''The part. The highlights. It's past the collar bone.''
According to the Times of India, an ''ultra-conservative'' British rabbi visited a temple ''as barbers severed the long tresses of women and men and saw it fall in a trough, from which it was collected to be sold to foreign buyers.
''Through a translator, he interviewed barbers, donors and temple guides, making copious notes.''
He reported to Elyashiv, who sounded the alarm.
South Florida's Orthodox rabbis seem willing to accept Indian wigs pending further evidence.
''We made some investigations,'' said Rabbi Neal Turk of Miami Beach's Beth Israel, a 225-family congregation in which, he said, perhaps half the women cover their hair.
According to Turk, Hindu scholars say that Hindu women cutting their hair is ''not a form of worship.''
Yael Putney of Miami Beach worried that three of her five wigs ''would be at issue. I was particularly concerned about one I paid a lot of money for . . . So I do what I always do: go online, and oh indeed, there was a controversy.''
Putney, 53, called her rabbi, Avika Stolper of congregation Ohr Chaim, who told her to keep wearing her wigs.
This is not the first time the wig issue has surfaced, said Rabbi Turk, noting that while Jewish law never changes, rabbis must interpret it in contemporary contexts.
But his opinions have had little impact in the Lubavitch community, which takes its cues from its own leaders. They decided that ''based on Jewish law, you don't have to get rid of the wigs,'' said Rabbi Joseph Korf of Hollywood's Community Synagogue Chabad Lubavitch.
His wife, Elisheva Korf, owns Elisheva's Wigs and Hair Boutique in North Miami Beach.
''A lot of companies have had to get rabbinical OK's,'' she said. ''That has caused the price of [approved] wigs to go up. Now I'm getting certificates that their wigs are kosher.''
הטקסט שלך כאן